Solid every time. The pizza is a combination of NY style with a crispy, Ohio style crust. Service is always fast and courteous also. We love having this shop just around the corner from our house.

-Brent R.

Always get delivered but the food is 💯 every time everything is so good and the same every time warning if u try u will be addicted

-Jordan H.

This is the most authentic Italian pizza in Columbus. It’s just exquisite. It’s not Brooklyn or Chicago pizza, just regular good old Ohio-like pizza. But it’s made with real ingredients and by someone who either was trained by an Italian or is Italian.

-Hannah S.

Hands down the best pizza in all of Columbus.
Whenever I crave pizza Castello Pizza is what comes to my mind.

-Khalid T.